The Great Gatsby
No. 01
MADE-FOR-TV MISFIRE

The Great Gatsby

Robert Markowitz · 2000 · 90m · Drama, Romance

"Paul Rudd as Nick Carraway is the only reason to press play."

A made-for-TV adaptation that treats Fitzgerald's masterwork like a Cliff's Notes assignment. Toby Stephens tries his best as Gatsby, Mira Sorvino is miscast as Daisy, and Paul Rudd as Nick Carraway is the only reason anyone remembers this exists. It has the production value of a History Channel reenactment.

28%
Critics
35%
Audience
Watch If

you need to see Paul Rudd before he became Paul Rudd. That's it. That's the entire value proposition.

Skip If

you have literally any other option. This is the Gatsby that A&E made because the rights were cheap and someone had a free Sunday. It looks like it was shot in a Marriott ballroom.

Best Consumed WhilePRO

Unlock this with a Pro account for the full experience.

ScorecardThe Multi-Axis Verdict
Worth Your Time
2/10
Fun Factor
3/10
Originality
1/10
Visual Craft
2/10
Pretension Index
3/10
Rewatchability
2/10
Pro Only

The Multi-Axis Verdict

See exactly how this film scores across craft, emotion, rewatchability, and cultural impact.

Sign In to Unlock
DecisionShould You Actually Watch This?
Worth Your Friday?
NO1/10

Your Friday deserves better than this.

Date Night Score
2/10

Unless your date loves existential dread, pick something else.

Group Watch Value
3/10

Solo viewing recommended. This one clears a room.

Pro Only

Decision Tools

Worth your Friday night? Date night material? Group watch gold? Find out.

Sign In to Unlock
CompsIf You Liked This, Watch These
CastThe Players
AvailabilityWhere to Watch
Stream It
Included with subscription
Not available
Rent It
Digital rental
Buy It
Own it digitally
Pro Only

The Discourse

Join the conversation. Pro members get access to the full discussion thread.

Sign In to Unlock